top of page

The New Race for Mars: Who Will Return the First Samples?

Nov 1
4 min read





For decades, scientists have dreamed of returning samples from Mars to Earth. Widely regarded as the holy grail of planetary science, Martian samples could provide unprecedented insights into whether life once existed on the Red Planet, and perhaps even whether it may still persist today. We have landed rovers the size of a small car, drilled rocks, flown a quadcopter, and cached carefully selected cores across the Martian surface.


Yet, the immense technical challenge of sending back material from the Red Planet has proved too much for space agencies and the politicians who fund them; the combined NASA/ESA Mars sample return mission was recently cancelled (see post).


Two missions are currently competing to make this long-held dream a reality, one Japanese and the other Chinese, and both hope to return samples by 2031. Intriguingly, the first Martian material to reach Earth may not come directly from Mars! Rather, it could be collected from Phobos, one of the planet's moons (see image), whose surface may contain debris ejected from Mars by ancient impacts.


On the 20th of October, the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) launched its Martian Moons eXploration mission, better known as MMX, aiming to collect at least 10 grams of material from Phobos, Mars's larger moon, and return those samples to Earth in 2031. If successful, it will become the first sample return mission from the Martian system.


At first glance, this may seem like a detour. Why study a small, oddly shaped moon when Mars itself is the obvious prize? The answer lies in a fascinating possibility: Phobos may have spent billions of years quietly collecting pieces of Mars, including material ejected from the planet during ancient asteroid impacts. Some of those fragments could date back to a period when Mars was warmer, wetter, and potentially habitable. And that raises an irresistible question. Could Phobos be preserving evidence of ancient Martian life? I explored the possibility of such evidence for ancient Earth life on our own Moon in my first-ever post published here.


This possibility makes MMX particularly exciting. The mission was primarily designed to answer a long-standing mystery: where did Phobos and its smaller companion Deimos come from? Scientists remain divided between two principal ideas. One possibility is that the moons are captured asteroids. The other is that they formed from debris thrown into orbit after a giant collision involving Mars billions of years ago. The composition of returned samples should help resolve this debate. Yet, hidden within those same samples may be something equally valuable: traces of ancient biological signatures. Finding such traces in material that predates much of Mars's geological alteration, which occurred billions of years ago, would be even more valuable.


MMX is not a direct Mars sample return mission, though. Most of the material collected will almost certainly be native to Phobos itself. Furthermore, any Martian fragments present within the regolith are likely to be tiny and mixed among vastly larger quantities of local material. Separating them will require painstaking laboratory work. Scientists will need to identify grains whose chemical and isotopic fingerprints clearly point to a Martian origin. Nevertheless, this mission strikes me as an exceptionally smart approach. By leveraging JAXA’s hard-earned experience from the successful Hayabusa and Hayabusa2 missions, it provides a relatively low-cost means of returning valuable samples while avoiding the technical complexities and risks associated with lifting off from Mars itself.


In contrast, the Chinese space agency (CNSA) has decided to confront the Mars sample-return challenge head-on, pursuing a mission that will collect samples directly from the Martian surface and return them to Earth. China's Tianwen-3 mission is designed to collect pristine material from the surface of Mars and bring it back to Earth for laboratory analysis. The mission is currently scheduled for launch during the favourable Mars transfer window of late 2028, with sample return targeted for 2031.


Unlike a conventional Mars lander, Tianwen-3 is a complex multi-spacecraft mission. The current design calls for two separate launches aboard Long March 5 rockets from the Wenchang Space Launch Site. The mission will consist of a Mars lander, a Mars ascent vehicle mounted on the lander, an orbiter/service module, and an Earth-return capsule. After collecting samples, the ascent vehicle will perform one of the mission's most challenging manoeuvres by launching from Mars and docking autonomously with the waiting orbiter. The samples will then be transferred to the Earth-return vehicle for the journey home.


China plans to return at least 500 grams of Martian material. The mission's sampling strategy is particularly ambitious, combining multiple collection techniques, including surface scooping, drilling and aerial or remote sampling. Chinese scientists have indicated that drilling could reach depths of up to two metres, potentially accessing material that has been shielded from surface radiation for billions of years.

The mission's primary scientific objective is the search for evidence of past or present life on Mars. Researchers hope the returned samples may contain preserved biosignatures, organic molecules, or geochemical clues that reveal whether Mars was once habitable.


Which mission will be the first to return samples from the Martian system: JAXA's MMX or CNSA's Tianwen-3? Given that MMX is a considerably simpler mission and is already on its way, I would be inclined to place my bet on the Japanese spacecraft. However, China's space programme has built an impressive track record of success with its robotic missions to both the Moon and Mars. As a result, it would be unwise to underestimate Tianwen-3's chances of success, despite the extraordinary technical challenges inherent in returning samples directly from the Martian surface.


One final thought. After spending decades building the most ambitious Mars exploration programme in history, NASA now risks watching others claim one of its ultimate prizes: the return of samples from Mars. Its inability to secure sustained political support for a sample-return campaign has left the field open to new challengers. The fact that the leading contenders, JAXA's MMX and CNSA's Tianwen-3, are both Asian missions is, in my view, a powerful illustration of a trend I highlighted in April: Western space agencies are no longer the uncontested leaders of deep-space exploration (see post here).


The balance is shifting, and the race to answer humanity's biggest questions about life beyond Earth is becoming increasingly global. This is a good thing for us all!


As always, onwards and upwards.

Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/University of Arizona

 
 
 

Comments


Copyright Bernard Henin 2026

bottom of page